Can You Keep a Secret? The Caribbean's Best Hidden Gems

Mount Cinnamon is an upscale boutique hotel on a hillside in Grenada, one of the Caribbean’s most underrated islands. Overlooking Grand Anse Beach, its 36 spacious villas and suites feature colorful, contemporary decor. The resort's excellent beach cabana area is its stand-out feature, providing a relaxed oasis with comfortable loungers and daybeds, a bar and cafe, and games in a lovely garden.

With only four rooms, Bellavista Bed & Breakfast is a relaxing and upscale hilltop retreat with personalized service from the owners, who live right next door. Though St. Thomas is certainly a popular getaway, this property provides a charming and quaint oasis with gorgeous harbor views. The island-style decor is whimsical and fun, yet tasteful, and quirky touches such as a cactus garden give the property character and personality. Breakfast is one of the best parts of the stay -- it’s two courses and feels decadent but still healthy.

With 25 freestanding cottages along a 20-acre bird sanctuary, this hilly resort is one of just a handful of hotels on Harbour Island. Understated sophistication is the vibe here; the grounds are peaceful (except for the roaming roosters), and most guests seem happy to spend their days simply soaking up the sun at Pink Sands Beach -- a beautiful and unspoiled three-mile stretch of sand from which the resort takes its name. There's great dining on-site, but guests can take a golf cart to other parts of this charming island for more restaurant choices.

These 29 studio, one-, two- or three-bedroom apartments along a secluded local beach are owned and/or managed by a charismatic Canadian couple. Units are located in the main Villa Tropical building, neighboring buildings along the coast (higher floors have better views), or across the street. The first-floor office is the hub for morning coffee and water sports equipment rentals (such as surfboards and stand-up paddleboards); maps of the best snorkel spots and underground caves are available here, too, and staff can give recommendations of excellent restaurants nearby.

Tucked far back in Negril's West End, the Westender Inn is a secluded cliffside boutique with a mix of 24 oceanside rooms and suites, spacious garden villas, and log cabin suites. This mid-range, spilt-road property offers a tasty restaurant, two bars, two pools, a small sandy beach (hard to find in the West End), and well-cared-for garden grounds. Because of its remote location, it's ideal for couples or large groups seeking a relaxing and private Jamaican holiday.

Nonsuch Bay is an upscale resort on a secluded corner of the tranquil island of Antigua. It features 62 contemporary apartment-style rooms with full kitchens, three pools, a pleasant beach, and a sailing club. Though the one restaurant is excellent, dining options are very limited due to the resort's remote location. With fewer activity options than at some more prominent family resorts, peace and relaxation are the order of the day at Nonsuch.

If the name “Atlantis” conjures up images of the megaresort in the Bahamas, then think again. The Atlantis Hotel in Barbados -- a historic property from the 1800s with only eight rooms -- is the polar opposite. The boutique hotel re-opened in 2009 and offers freshly decorated nautical-themed rooms with canopy beds, stylish furnishings, and modern amenities. Located on the remote and rocky east coast, the beach is more suitable for surfing than swimming, and a car is recommended to get around the island.

Opened in 2024, this luxury resort spans 28 acres and offers 56 guestrooms and 15 villas, each with private pools and breathtaking sea views. The resort emphasizes sustainability and integrates seamlessly into the natural landscape. Get a treatment at the two-story on-site spa that overlooks the lagoon, or try one of their wellness programs while you are there- choosing from a yoga program, detox, fitness or sleep. They offer several experiences to truly immerse yourself in the Grenadian culture, five dining options, a pool, beach, daily activities and more.

Another new hotel, Hotel Indigo Grand Cayman on Seven Mile Beach, features over 280 guest rooms and an infinity pool overlooking the ocean. It's a modern addition to Grand Cayman, known for its exceptional scuba diving and snorkeling opportunities. Likely not to be a hidden gem much longer, thanks to its stellar amenities, including a beach club, bicycles, pool, 4 restaurants, and a beachfront.

This chic 24-room retreat is the perfect tropical luxury getaway spot. The hotel offers a serene ambiance, making it a perfect addition to your list of hidden gems. The rooms are spacious, with private balconies, terraces, and private pools for the utmost serenity. There is an onsite spa, restaurant and bar, beach access, and some watersports are included.